  | Full Text Reviews: School Library Journal - 11/01/2014 Gr 4–8—In the quiet village of Nnewtown, live the Nnewts, a happy community of amphibians. Herk is a young Nnewt confined to his home's spawning pool because his legs are not strong enough to support his body. When Nnewtown is attacked by the evil Lizzarks, Herk's parents are killed and he is forced to flee. Alone on this journey and pursued by the Lizzarks, he encounters several characters who help him grow and confront the Snake Lord, the villain who replaced his original strong legs with weaker ones while Herk was still an egg. The first volume of a new graphic novel series by the creator of Bad Island (2011) and Cardboard (2012, both Scholastic), this originally appeared online as a web-comic. While Tennapel creates a generally uplifting story, there are several inexplicably strange turns and occurrences. Most notable among these is in Herk's victory over the Snake Lord when the constellation Orion, which the book does establish as a focus of worship for Nnewt culture, suddenly takes an active role in the story's events, deus ex machina-style. There's also a potential tone-deafness toward students with disabilities, presenting Herk's originally weak legs, described at one point as "withered," as an obstacle that must be fixed in order to achieve completeness. Tennapel's cartoonish illustrations are the work's strength, and its intended audience will find them exciting and humorous. It may be best to wait and see how the story progresses in the next installment before adding this to a graphic novel collection.—Ryan F. Paulsen, New Rochelle High School, NY - Copyright 2014 Publishers Weekly, Library Journal and/or School Library Journal used with permission. Booklist - 12/15/2014 A small village of peaceful nnewts has fallen victim to a surprise attack from their worst enemies. Herk, a young nnewt unable to walk yet, witnesses much of the violence—his father is eaten by a weretoad, his mother is slaughtered by lizzarks, and his sister has been abducted. Swimming away from his village, Herk goes on a quest to find his legs and the magic that will help him avenge his family. Though the labyrinthine plot and dialogue may lead TenNapel’s fans to feel that this work isn’t as outstanding as Bad Island (2011) or Cardboard (2012), his signature cartoon style nonetheless shines through, and in typical fashion, he presents an edgy story, adding touching death and afterlife scenes for Herk’s family that some children’s writers wouldn’t touch. The action-heavy panels, packed with lots of motion and sound effects, make this a great fit for reluctant readers, especially those who like fantasy adventure tales. Kids drawn in by Herk’s quest will be happy to know there are more adventures to come. - Copyright 2014 Booklist. Bulletin for the Center... - 03/01/2015 In this graphic novel, amphibians and reptiles are enemies, and Herk, a amphibious Nnewt who may be lacking strength but certainly isn’t lacking bravado is the only one left to avenge his village after the reptilian Lizzarks brutally attack. Herk’s legs don’t work well, but an encounter with a magical being helps him discover that his true legs were actually stolen, and once he has them back, Herk’s even more determined to defeat the bad guys, even though he knows it won’t regain him his family. Nnewts began as a serial webcomic, but this volume reads as a smooth, seamless graphic novel that will feel like home to fans and be a comfortable starting point for newbies; TenNapel strikes the proper balance of providing enough background exposition without boring his existing audience. Sharp, detailed illustrations feature cartoonish characters against rich earth colors and watery blues. While text and illustrations mostly mirror each other, occasional wordless panels are perfectly placed to slow the reader or increase impact of a key scene. Since the illustrations read a bit young for the tragedy and intense drama of the text, readers’ advisory finesse will allow librarians to guide selection for those who don’t already know the author. Final art not seen. AS - Copyright 2015 The Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois. Loading...
 |